Skip to Main Content
 

ATSU Library Research Hub

This hub page pulls together information about research support services provided by the Library and other departments of ATSU

What are the types of reviews?

  Purpose Features Time Frame Example Question
Literature Review (Narrative Review)
  • Provide an overview and synthesis of published work on a topic
  • Background chapters, proposals, when developing a new research question, or building background, theory
  • Selective search (not comprehensive)
  • No formal quality appraisal
  • Thematic or chronological organization
  • Author interprets and synthesizes findings
  • Output Type: Narrative summary
  • 3-6 months
  • What is currently known about mindfulness interventions in schools?
Case Study
  • Provide an in-depth description of a single case or small group
  • Rare, novel, or illustrative cases in clinical, educational, or organizational contexts or illustrating unique cases
  • Descriptive and retrospective
  • Focuses on detailed observation, not causation
  • Follows CARE Guidelines (clinical)
  • Output Type: In-depth report
  • Varies
  • How did an innovative sensory integration approach impact one child with autism?
Scoping Review
  • Explore the breadth of evidence, map key concepts, and identify knowledge gaps
  • Broad or emerging topics where research questions are not yet clearly defined, or exploring and identifying gaps
  • Broad, exploratory scope
  • Comprehensive search, reproducible search (includes grey literature)
  • Explicit inclusion/exclusion criteria
  • No formal quality appraisal required
  • Identifies research gaps and conceptual definitions
  • Uses PRISMA-ScR and JBI frameworks
  • Output Type: Evidence map
  • ~12 months
  • What research exists on non-pharmaceutical treatments for ADHD?
Systematic Review
  • Answer a focused question using all available high-quality evidence
  • Clinical, educational, or policy questions that need evidence-based recommendations, or answering focused questions
  • Comprehensive, reproducible search (includes grey literature)
  • Explicit inclusion/exclusion criteria
  • Requires critical appraisal and risk of bias assessment
  • Follows PRISMA 2020 and Cochrane/JBI guidelines
  • Output Type: Evidence synthesis
  • ~12 months
  • Is Cognitive Behavioral Therapy effective in treating ADHD in young adults?
Meta-Analysis
  • Statistically combine results from multiple studies to produce a precise estimate of effect
  • Quantitative data synthesis across comparable studies quantifying effects
  • Often part of a systematic review
  • Uses statistical methods to pool findings
  • Requires homogeneous studies and quality appraisal
  • Follows PRISMA 2020 guidelines
  • Output Type: Statistical synthesis
  • ~12 months
  • What is the pooled effect of physical activity interventions on adolescent anxiety?
Rapid Review
  • Quickly summarize available evidence to support urgent decision-making
  • Policy or clinical settings where time and resources are limited
  • Fast decision support
  • Condensed version of a systematic review
  • Search and appraisal may be abbreviated
  • Follows Cochrane Rapid Review or WHO guidance
  • Output Type: Evidence summary
  • Varies
  • What evidence supports telehealth in occupational therapy during public health emergencies?
Bibliometric Analysis
  • Quantitatively analyze research patterns, impact, and trends within a field
  • Understanding how a topic has evolved, who the key contributors are, and where research is headed
  • Tracking field evolution
  • Uses citation, co-citation, and keyword analysis
  • Identifies influential authors, journals, and institutions
  • Follows Bibliometrix (Aria & Cuccurullo, 2017) and PRISMA-S for search reporting
  • Quantitative, data-driven approach
  • Output Type: Statistical trends/maps
  • Varies
  • What are the global publication trends in occupational therapy education from 2000–2024?

Pyramid of Evidence